Rings of Power vs the books: 7 season 3 changes Tolkien never wrote, and one he'd recognize

Rings of Power vs the books: 7 season 3 changes Tolkien never wrote, and one he'd recognize
Image credit: Legion Media

Gandalf's hat looks exactly as it ought to. It's when you ask where he got it that somebody has to go and fetch the appendices. Season 3 does this sort of thing a lot.

Six episodes into The Rings of Power season 3, we've seen Gandalf get dressed, Galadriel find her husband and Sauron shop around for something to melt. Tolkien would have recognized everybody in that sentence. He might have had a few questions about their afternoon.

1. Gandalf goes hat shopping at Tom Bombadil's

In episode 3, Tom disappears and Gandalf picks up the hat he left behind. Daniel Weyman told Extra what he had to work out about that moment. Bilbo's account in The Hobbit is rather less complicated. A wizard in a tall blue hat turns up at his door. Nobody offers a receipt. There's also a small matter of timing. Appendix B of The Lord of the Rings places the wizards' arrival in Middle-earth around a thousand years into the Third Age. Númenor is already at the bottom of the sea by then.

2. Pallando gets a criminal record

Ciarán Hinds's Dark Wizard turns out to be Pallando, one of the two Blue Wizards. Tolkien did send wizards east. He tried out quite different fates for them, at one point imagining that they founded secret cults, elsewhere crediting them with weakening Sauron's forces. He never wrote the episode in which Gandalf learns that this particular wizard terrorized Rhûn. Showrunner J.D. Payne called the eastern wizards “such a tantalising piece of the lore”. You can see the attraction. Tolkien left him a name and a forwarding address.

3. Theo gets a ring and a family tree

Bronwyn's boy survives a fight for one of the Nine when Sauron personally disposes of his last opponent. Then Sauron tells him his father belonged to a line of stewards of Mordor. The ring is real enough. The genealogy comes courtesy of the fellow trying to talk him into wearing it.

Cynthia Addai-Robinson as Míriel in The Rings of Power (2022). The show gives her a season 3 storyline about regaining her sight that Tolkien never wrote.
Cynthia Addai-Robinson as Míriel in The Rings of Power (2022). The show gives her a season 3 storyline about regaining her sight that Tolkien never wrote. Image credit: Legion Media

Tolkien left most of the Nine anonymous. There's room for the writers to invent a Southlander who takes a ring. What gets me is how little use they make of the most interesting thing about that choice.

Apparently a village healer's son can't even make a terrible decision on his own merits. First he needs a distinguished grandfather.

Tolkien's Men had an excellent reason to take what Sauron offered. They were going to die, and here was someone who seemed able to do something about it. That would have worked on a healer's son, too.

4. Celeborn spends centuries in orc custody

Season 3 finds Galadriel's missing husband in Gundabad. A captive Celeborn gives the couple a lovely reunion and gives the writers an answer to the question of where he's been all this time. In Unfinished Tales, Tolkien left several accounts of the couple's travels. In one, Celeborn is fighting in the defense of Eregion. None requires Galadriel to spring her husband from an orc prison.

5. Sauron needs Fëanor's hammer for scrap

In episode 6, Sauron takes Galadriel's shape to coax a secret from Celeborn. Once he learns that metal from Valinor went into the Three, he sets his sights on melting down Fëanor's hammer for the One. In Tolkien's “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age,” Sauron forges the One in Orodruin and puts much of his own strength into it. That's what makes losing the thing so catastrophically expensive for him. Tolkien managed to explain the stakes without asking the reader to keep track of a hammer.

Don't miss: Who is Theo in Rings of Power? The show's Mary Sue now has a secret bloodline and one of the Nine Rings

6. Gil-galad gives Míriel back her sight

The High King uses his ring to restore Míriel's vision in episode 6. The writers had some leeway on the cure since they also invented the injury. Tolkien's “Akallabêth” gives Míriel a stolen throne, a disastrous marriage and a last, desperate climb up the mountain as Númenor drowns. It never takes her eyesight.

7. Pharazôn proposes a coalition marriage

The show has Pharazôn suggest marriage as a way to unite two camps. In the published “Akallabêth,” he takes Míriel to wife against her will and seizes the scepter. He's her first cousin, which also puts the marriage on the wrong side of Númenórean law. Same two names on the wedding invitation. Quite a different answer to the question of who got to say yes.

And the one Tolkien would recognize? Khamûl the Easterling

Zubin Varla's horse-lord accepts one of the Nine. His particular encounter with Sauron belongs to the show, but Khamûl really is an Easterling who becomes a Ringwraith, second to the Witch-king. Christopher Tolkien published his father's notes on him in “The Hunt for the Ring,” part of Unfinished Tales.

There's even a face, or rather a hood, you can put to the name. In Tolkien's account of the hunt, Khamûl is the Black Rider who comes to Hobbiton asking the Gaffer about Baggins. Of all the people in season 3 to come with genuine literary credentials, it's the one who had to ask Sam's dad for directions.

Previously we wrote: Who is Rings of Power's Man with the White Flame? Aragorn's sword holds the clue