Survivor 51 elimination order: every boot so far, plus who goes home Wednesday

Survivor 51 elimination order: every boot so far, plus who goes home Wednesday
Image credit: Legion Media

Kristin Flickinger and Danny Kilby went home on a single vote. Every other vote cast that night was cancelled out.

That's Survivor 51 in one Tribal Council. The season premiered on CBS on September 23 with 21 castaways and 26 days in Fiji's Mamanuca Islands. It's the first season of what Jeff Probst calls the "open era," in which any twist from the show's past can return. Eight episodes in, plenty have, and ten players are left.

Survivor 51 elimination order so far

  1. Aaliyah Puglia (Toka), episode 1 — voted out 6–2 on Day 3. She played her Shot in the Dark, and it didn't save her.
  2. Ana Sani (Savu), episode 2 — voted out 6–4 on Day 5. The tribe had been leaning toward Eric Macksoud until Ana's name-dropping around camp made her the bigger target.
  3. Rob Antonson (Savu), episode 3 — quit on Day 6, worried that a leg injury would get infected. Medical found a cut on his foot and nothing that would have pulled him from the game.
  4. Patt Cannaday (Toka), episode 3 — voted out 6–5 on Day 7.
  5. Jenna Doore (Savu), episode 4 — voted out 4–1 on Day 9. She started on Toka and switched tribes in the mutiny.
  6. Alexis Levine (Savu), episode 5 — voted out 3–1 on Day 10, after Jelly Loblack chose the Helicopter Alliance over her.
  7. Linnea Capobianco (Dina), episode 5 — out the same night. She and Lewis Kelly tied 4–4 twice, and the players outside the tie had to agree unanimously on who left. They chose Linnea.
  8. Ori Jean-Charles (Savu), episode 6 — voted out on Day 12 by the only two people left on his tribe, Jelly and Devin Way. His Shot in the Dark came back not safe.
  9. Brady Booker (Tovuto), episode 7 — blindsided 9–4 at the merge on Day 14. He became the first juror, then asked to go home to treat his injured thumb and gave up his jury seat.
  10. Kristin Flickinger (Tovuto), episode 8 — eliminated with her partner in the Double Duo twist. She's now the first member of the jury.
  11. Danny Kilby (Tovuto), episode 8 — went out with Kristin and became the second juror.

Still in the game: Carter Krull, Cristian Chavez, Devin Way, Eric Macksoud, Jelly Loblack, Lewis Kelly, Maggie Nestor, Mike Pinsky, Sharonda Cox and Thien An Nguyen. That's six original Tokas and four original Savus.

How the Double Duo worked

Episode 8 brought back the Double Duo from season 50. The 12 players paired up, competed for immunity as pairs, and learned that one pair would be voted out together.

"It's a social game. It's about the relationships you form," Probst said.

The pairs were Carter and Cristian, Mike and Maggie, Sharonda and Lewis, Kilby and Kristin, Jelly and Devin, and Eric and Thien An. Sharonda and Lewis won immunity. Then Tribal Council fell apart in order:

  • Jelly played her idol for herself and Devin, cancelling eight votes against them.
  • Cristian played his Shot in the Dark, came back safe, and cancelled the one vote against him and Carter.
  • Kristin played hers too. It came back not safe.

That left one vote standing: Devin's, against Kristin and Kilby. Eight people tried to send Devin home, and he ended up being the one who decided who left.

Don't miss: The heartbreaking reason Love Is Blind's only Boston marriage fell apart

Who goes home Wednesday

Episode 9, "Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub," airs Wednesday, November 18, on CBS. Who goes home is anyone's guess until then, but the preview shows two ways out.

The first is the vote. CBS promises a massive idol hunt, and Devin has hidden the fake idol he and Jelly made before the merge. In the preview, Thien An names Jelly as her next target. Jelly and Devin survived episode 8 as the pair everyone voted against, and they're still the most obvious duo left.

The second is a coin.

"Tonight we are flipping the million-dollar coin," Probst says in the preview.

The rules are season 50's with one change. Whoever flips and calls it right gets immunity, and the prize goes up. As Probst put it before the season: "If they land it, the prize pool will be $2 million for 51." Call it wrong, and the flipper is out of the game on the spot, while the extra million rolls over to season 52.

In season 50, Rick Devens called it right, and Aubry Bracco went home with $2 million. This time, a wrong call sends someone home early and hands the money to people who haven't been cast yet.

Previously we wrote: Concrete proof that Joran van der Sloot has been lying all along