What is Amber Heard diagnosed with? Two psychologists testified under oath and reached opposite conclusions
If you watched the Depp–Heard trial on a Tuesday in April 2022, you heard a psychologist give a remarkably definite answer. If you tuned in the following Tuesday, you heard another psychologist give an equally definite answer. It mattered which Tuesday you picked.
On April 26, Dr. Shannon Curry, a forensic psychologist retained by Johnny Depp's lawyers, testified that Amber Heard's evaluation supported borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder. On May 3, Dr. Dawn Hughes, a forensic psychologist retained by Heard's lawyers, testified that she had diagnosed Heard with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). They had both examined Heard. They disagreed about what the evidence showed, most directly on whether she met the criteria for PTSD.
What Shannon Curry found
Curry spent roughly 12 hours evaluating Heard over two days in December 2021. She reviewed treatment records, interviewed Heard and used psychological tests, including a 567-item personality inventory. Asked in court what she'd concluded, Curry named both diagnoses.
“The results of Ms. Heard's evaluation supported two diagnoses: Borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder.”
Curry also testified that Heard's account of her symptoms during testing overstated their severity and that, in her assessment, Heard didn't meet the criteria for PTSD. Under questioning, Curry drew a distinction worth keeping. Someone can suffer psychological harm without developing that particular disorder. Even by Curry's own account, the PTSD finding could only answer so much.
What Dawn Hughes found
Hughes spent about 29 hours with Heard across six visits. She described interviewing Heard's former therapists, reviewing their records and administering psychological tests. In her May 3 testimony, Hughes attributed Heard's PTSD to what she assessed as intimate partner violence by Depp. Depp denied abusing Heard.

Hughes also explained why the therapists' notes mattered to her. A personality disorder involves a lasting pattern. Two therapists had each seen Heard over a period of years, Hughes testified, and neither had diagnosed a personality disorder. Hughes thought trauma better explained the symptoms she saw. When Depp's lawyer challenged how she had arrived at the PTSD diagnosis, Hughes gave this answer under cross-examination.
“I made my diagnosis during clinical interviewing and 11 other psychological tests that supported diagnosis of PTSD and symptomatology consistent with PTSD.”
That's the disagreement the jury heard. Curry thought the testing undercut the PTSD claim. Hughes thought the interviews, records and tests supported it. Neither was Heard's treating psychologist. Both were there to offer the court an opinion.
Don't miss: Johnny Depp is back at No. 1. Does Amber Heard have any upcoming projects?
What did the jury decide about her diagnosis?
Pull up the actual verdict form and look at what the jurors had to answer. They considered statements in Heard's 2018 op-ed and statements made by Depp's lawyer, Adam Waldman. They found for Depp on all three statements he challenged in Heard's op-ed and for Heard on one statement by Waldman.
The internet came away with a diagnosis. The jury went home without ever being asked to pick one.
That's why the date and the doctor's name belong in the answer. We know which diagnoses Curry and Hughes each gave in that Virginia courtroom in 2022. The verdict tells us nothing about what appears in Heard's medical chart today.
Previously we wrote: After Johnny Depp's trial with Amber Heard, his first studio movie in 8 years tops the box office