Gremlins 2 killed off a real critic for giving the first movie 2 stars
Six years after a bad review, Joe Dante put a VHS copy of Gremlins in the reviewer's hand and gave him another go. Ordinarily, this is the point where a director hopes the critic has reconsidered. Dante needed him in exactly the same mood.
The critic was Leonard Maltin, who gave Gremlins two stars out of four in his movie guide. In Gremlins 2: The New Batch, he plays himself on a TV show called Movie Police. Up comes the cassette. Off goes Maltin about the original movie. Then a couple of gremlins get a strip of film around his neck and settle the matter on the air. Film criticism must have felt like a safer profession before anybody thought of using 35mm for that.
The bad review was the one part Dante couldn't write for him
Maltin and Dante had known each other since they were teenagers in New Jersey. When Gremlins came out in 1984, Maltin was reviewing movies for Entertainment Tonight. At a newspaper he could have handed the assignment to somebody else. The TV show had one critic, and Steven Spielberg had produced the biggest little monsters of the summer. Sitting this one out would've taken some explaining.
Don't miss: 6 movies Tarantino calls perfect, from Jaws to an ’80s time-travel comedy
Maltin thought Dante had made a handsome, mean-spirited movie. He said so, and by Maltin's own account, the review put a strain on the friendship. When producer Mike Finnell called about the sequel, Maltin agreed to take his lumps. On the Warner Bros. soundstage, Dante gave him one direction: “Just use your own words.”
Joe Dante paid a critic the one professional courtesy Hollywood generally tries to avoid. He gave him final say on how bad his movie was.
That explains why the review sounds considerably more convincing than the average bit of movie-within-a-movie dialogue. Maltin improvised it. The monsters had to hit their marks. The man holding the videotape had been rehearsing for six years.

So what did he give the one that killed him?
Three stars out of four. In a release-week interview with the Los Angeles Times, Maltin sounded positively relieved to have enjoyed the experience on the audience's side of the screen, too.
“I’m glad that I’m in a better movie.”
He did have a reservation about the sequel: there were rather a lot of cameos. Fair enough from a man uniquely qualified to identify one. He also came away with two Topps trading cards featuring his appearance. Somewhere out there is a kid who opened a pack of monster cards hoping for Gizmo and got the film critic from Entertainment Tonight.
Previously we wrote: The slasher Gene Siskel hated so much he gave away the killer in the Chicago Tribune