Why did Jim die on From? Season 4 points back to the song Jade played

Why did Jim die on From? Season 4 points back to the song Jade played
Image credit: Legion Media

The man who kills Jim Matthews has time for exactly one piece of music criticism before he does it. Season 4 gives us a pretty good reason to take him at his word.

The Man in Yellow kills Jim for helping Tabitha and Jade remember what happened to their daughter. That's how Jade explains the murder to Boyd in season 4, and the killer supplies most of the evidence himself. He mentions Jade's tune just before tearing Jim's throat out. Then Jim's children find their father's body in the barn. Somebody has painted “Knowledge comes at a cost” on the wall. Now try explaining to those two kids why the song was worth playing.

What did Jim figure out?

The scraps of paper in the bottles look like dates. Jade has noticed that whoever wrote the numbers sometimes reversed the twos and sevens. Count those separately and he has twelve symbols. He's tried the zodiac, the months of the year and, by his own exasperated account, eggs in a carton.

Jim's mother taught piano. Twelve makes him think of the notes in a chromatic scale. Jade can play the violin, and now he has a tune.

David Alpay as Jade with his violin in From (2022). Jim helps Jade decipher the numbers that lead him to play the tune at the bottle tree
David Alpay as Jade with his violin in From (2022). Jim helps Jade decipher the numbers that lead him to play the tune at the bottle tree. Image credit: Legion Media

When he plays it at the bottle tree, the children appear. Tabitha and Jade finally understand anghkooey, the word the children have been saying to them: “remember.” They've been here before, in lives that include Miranda's and Christopher's. In their earliest life together, one of the children sacrificed in exchange for immortality was their own daughter. They tried to save her. Now they remember enough to try again.

Why kill Jim instead of the man with the violin?

Start with what the killer says to Jim by the RV: “That Jade sure can play.” Then he reminds Jim of the hole Tabitha dug under their house. Jim heard that warning the first time over his homemade radio in season 1. The man already knew who was asking questions. The song gave him a fresh reason to object to the answers.

In “Fray,” Jade tells Boyd precisely who he thinks the message in the barn was for.

“When we played the song at the tree, it was like something unlocked, and we finally understood.”

Jade's conclusion is “They killed Jim because of us.” Boyd recognizes the pattern. Sara warned him a long time ago that pushing too hard for answers would make something push back. Tabitha takes a considerably less philosophical view. She tells Jade she wishes he'd been the one to die.

Don't miss: Is Jack dead in Line of Fire? Episode 8 finally gave his mother an answer

Episode 8 gives Tabitha a chance to ask the Man in Yellow if he's going to kill her, too. He tells her he kept one of Jim's teeth. As for Tabitha, he calls her about the closest thing he's ever had to a friend. He wanted her alive, and he brought her to the spot where he killed her husband to tell her he'd kept a souvenir.

Why keep her alive to hear that? As showrunner Jeff Pinkner told ScreenRant after the finale, “it's the suffering that fuels him.” Think back to the barn. Killing Jim settles the score over the song. Hanging his body where his kids can find it gets the Man in Yellow a whole grieving family for the price of one murder.

Previously we wrote: Black Doves repeats the Netflix mistake that makes fans quit a hit show