Jessica Chastain's Netflix thriller hit No. 1 and still flopped

Jessica Chastain's Netflix thriller hit No. 1 and still flopped
Image credit: Legion Media

Jessica Chastain plays a washed-up country star who keeps her Grammy in the refrigerator next to the liquor. After the opening weekend Heartland just had, I have a suggestion for where Netflix can put the No. 1 trophy.

Heartland drew 7.3 million views from Friday, November 13, through Sunday. That made it the most-watched English-language film on Netflix worldwide for the week. It beat the runner-up, A Dog’s Perfect Christmas, by 100,000 views. The dog had already been on the service for a week.

Put the timing the other way around and the win looks rather different. On its opening chart, the Christmas movie drew 8.6 million views. It had a two-day head start thanks to a Wednesday release, so let’s give Chastain a fairer field.

How much does a Netflix movie usually need on opening weekend?

In a comparison of 23 recent movie debuts, What’s on Netflix put Heartland in 22nd place. Only Best of the Best, with 4.3 million views, opened lower. You don’t even have to invoke Matt Damon and Ben Affleck’s The Rip, which did 41.6 million, to see the problem.

Don't miss: Netflix's No. 1 show doesn't tell you a single thing you didn't already know

The film smack in the middle of that list is People We Meet on Vacation, at 17.2 million. That’s a romance about two friends with a complicated travel history. Heartland could double its opening and still finish 2.6 million views behind them.

Netflix found a perfectly accurate way to call the 22nd-best opening in a field of 23 a win. It changed the question to “What else did you watch this weekend?”

It’s a frustrating result for a thriller with an actual idea for its lead. Chastain’s Misty Jones comes out of seclusion to look for her missing niece, played by country singer Carter Faith. Writer-director Shana Feste had Humphrey Bogart’s detectives in mind. As Chastain put it when she described Misty, “She survived fame by walking away from it.” Now the one person in Nashville who wanted out has to knock on all those doors again.

Chastain’s other Netflix No. 1 looked rather different

In 2022, Chastain played the nurse who began to suspect her colleague, Eddie Redmayne, of killing patients in The Good Nurse. That thriller also debuted at No. 1. Back then, Netflix counted 68.31 million hours watched. Divide by its two-hour, three-minute runtime, the way Netflix calculates views today, and you get roughly 33.3 million views in five days. The Good Nurse had Wednesday and Thursday on its side. There was also a considerably bigger audience on the other end of the calculation.

Jessica Chastain as Amy Loughren in The Good Nurse (2022). Her earlier Netflix thriller also opened at No. 1 and drew roughly 33.3 million views in five days
Jessica Chastain as Amy Loughren in The Good Nurse (2022). Her earlier Netflix thriller also opened at No. 1 and drew roughly 33.3 million views in five days. Image credit: Legion Media

Three days tell us how Heartland opened. They tell us precious little about its eventual audience or what Netflix paid for it. But for anyone wondering how two Jessica Chastain thrillers could both get the exact same billing, there it is. The number on the badge only goes up to one. The difference in how many people watched can run into the millions.

Previously we wrote: Black Doves repeats the Netflix mistake that makes fans quit a hit show