The Office paid $60,000 for one Michael Scott joke in its Christmas episode

The Office paid $60,000 for one Michael Scott joke in its Christmas episode
Image credit: Legion Media

There are two office parties, a trip to Benihana and a perfectly good family photograph sacrificed to Michael Scott's love life in this episode. If you'd asked me which bit cost sixty grand, I'd have kept guessing for a while.

It's the Eddie Money song. Early in season 3's “A Benihana Christmas,” Michael tells the documentary crew he's taking his girlfriend Carol to Sandals in Jamaica. He sings a scrap of “Two Tickets to Paradise,” then adjusts the departure date to fit his booking. Getting the song cleared cost The Office $60,000. Carol isn't even in the room to hear it.

The part where Michael should probably have kept the receipt

Carol does come by the office. She's carrying the Christmas card Michael made out of a photo of her family on a ski trip. That's Carol in the picture. Those are her kids. The body standing beside them belongs to her ex-husband, whose head Michael has replaced with his own.

Nancy Carell plays the scene beautifully. Carol has come in holding physical evidence that her boyfriend has pasted himself into her children's memories. Michael would like to know whether the promise of an all-inclusive resort might move the conversation along. She breaks up with him. He still has the tickets.

Sixty thousand dollars to announce a vacation. Michael loses his traveling companion over a Christmas card he made himself.

What makes the song worth keeping, at least to those of us spending somebody else's money, is that Michael has bothered to fix the lyric. He's fine with passing off another man's ski trip as his own, but he won't mislead a documentary crew about which day his plane leaves.

Don't miss: The Big Bang Theory wanted this Home Alone star so badly he had to turn it down 3 times

Nobody told the writer what Eddie Money cost

Jen Celotta wrote the episode. By the time she learned the price, Steve Carell had sung the line and she was sitting at the sound mix. On Office Ladies, Celotta recalled the moment somebody finally told her.

“And at the sound mix, I found out from Kent that that was a 60,000 dollar joke.”

There's a whole karaoke party later in the same episode. Kevin sings, Kelly sings, and Creed gets to do a number of his own. The bill Celotta was talking about belonged to Michael's little Eddie Money impression before the party got going. A few words sung to that tune were enough to require clearance.

Steve Carell and John Krasinski as Michael and Jim in The Office's A Benihana Christmas (2006). The episode paid to clear Michael's brief rendition of Two Tickets to Paradise.
Steve Carell and John Krasinski as Michael and Jim in The Office's A Benihana Christmas (2006). The episode paid to clear Michael's brief rendition of Two Tickets to Paradise. Image credit: Legion Media

Celotta remembered losing some of the show's music budget not long afterward. She wondered about the timing. Nobody told her the two things were connected. As for Michael, he eventually finds somebody to take the spare ticket. Jan says yes. In retrospect, the song may have been the cheaper mistake.

Previously we wrote: The Sopranos star HBO paid $3 million to keep off The Office